SEEKER TO SEEKER

SEEKER TO SEEKER

Letters

False Compassion

Choosing to help or needing to help?

Simeon B. Mihaylov's avatar
Simeon B. Mihaylov
Nov 16, 2026
∙ Paid
The Return of the Prodigal Son by Rembrandt (Rembrandt van Rijn) Dutch (detail)

Dear friends,

For a long time, I’ve felt a mixture of fascination and discomfort at two powerful scenes from The Farthest Shore, book 3 of Ursula K. Le Guin’s Earthsea series. Recently, I gained a new understanding of why these scenes mean so much to me, and I think they might give you food for thought as well.

I will not spoil the book (I strongly recommend reading the whole series!), but let me briefly sketch out both scenes.

Scene 1: A boy is captured on a slaver’s ship. The boy’s mentor—a powerful mage—appears in a flash of light. The mage casts a spell to destroy the shackles of every slave on the ship, and then teleports himself and the boy away. Later, the boy asks his mentor why he left the rest of the slaves behind with the armed slavers on the ship. The mage replies:

“I left none bound on that ship… [The slavers] may be dead by now, or chained by the others to be sold as slaves; but I left them free to fight or bargain… I will not make their choices for them, nor will I let them make mine for me!”

My initial reaction was the same as the boy’s. Why wouldn’t the mage use his power to set things right? Why not punish those who are evil and preserve those who are innocent when he has the power to do so?

Scene 2: The mage is now in the land of the dead on a quest to restore the balance of the universe. There, he encounters an old friend. His friend has entered that realm out of sheer foolishness and has now lost his way back. The mage greets the man and tells him where to exit the realm and return to the land of the living. His friend, trembling, says he cannot possibly find the way.

“Maybe thou shalt,” says the mage, embraces his friend, and then continues on his path.

When first I read this, I wanted to step into the novel and implore the mage to save his friend, to not leave him stranded among the shades… To have compassion! At the same time, I had the uneasy feeling that my own compulsion was somehow immature.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Simeon B. Mihaylov.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Simeon B. Mihaylov · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.